In spite of my bias, it's hard to argue against a more iconic setting for College GameDay than the University of Notre Dame. Pat McAfee and Co. set up shop on the library lawn, with Touchdown Jesus as their backdrop. And when Riley the Leprechaun and Michael Milano, a junior pre-med student at Notre Dame, kicked the football through the uprights (on the second attempt), all seemed right with the world. The Risen Lord was looking down, the crowd was sending volley cheers on high, and the thunder had clearly been shaken down.
Yet, as I watched the scene unfold, I found myself wishing Notre Dame would change something. In fact, I think it should. I believe it's time for the University to update Touchdown Jesus. Here's the story, and here is my reason why.
My freshman and junior year roommate at Notre Dame, Megan, was ahead of her time. A philosophy and theology major, Megan rarely let a lunch pass without a provocative question sparked by a course lecture or an article in The Observer.
In honor of 50 years of undergraduate women, the Alumni Association unveiled new lyrics to the Victory March. As written on FightingIrish.com,
The original lyrics, written when all athletes at Notre Dame were male, refer to ‘sons,’ but in recognition of the fact that the ‘Victory March’ is now played for athletic teams composed of men and women, many modified the words accordingly. In 2022, after 114 years, the lyrics were modified. Previously, the lyrics said, “While her loyal sons are marching onward to victory.” Now, the lyrics say “While her loyal sons and daughters march on to victory.”
Megan had been singing this version on her own since our freshman year. Unprompted.
The controversy over the Christopher Columbus murals in Notre Dame's Main Building began in October 1995. Students protested, calling the murals offensive and demanding their removal during an upcoming renovation. Megan believed the twelve paintings glorified colonization. The university covered them with tapestries in 2020.
She also knew that the iconic mural on the Hesburgh Library wasn’t officially called Touchdown Jesus. It was The Word of Life, depicting the Risen Christ alongside apostles and Doctors of the Church. Megan pointed out who was missing: women.
Although such questions, observations, and insights aren't uncommon today, in Megan I found a new perspective. I want Megan to know how much I appreciate her discerning mind. And I want the world to know she was on to something. I believe it's time for Touchdown Jesus to change. Here's why.
The idea for the Word of Life mural originated with Father Theodore Hesburgh, C.S.C., for whom the building on which it stands is named. Father Ted wanted to express how Catholic faith and the pursuit of knowledge complement one another, and he commissioned artist Millard Sheets to bring that vision to life. Sheets envisioned Christ as the great teacher, surrounded by the Apostles, various saints, and renowned scholars and thinkers throughout history.
The Word of Life mural celebrates the continuity of human wisdom, faith, scholarship, and the pursuit of truth across the centuries. Yet women, who contributed enormously to all four, are conspicuously absent. Megan was right.
I thought about this lacuna. Mary, the mother of Jesus and the greatest of all saints, has her own place atop the Dome. But what about the hundreds of women who have shaped the history of our Church? Women have long been theologians, scholars, and saints. I remember from Church history that Pope Paul VI declared two women—Sts. Teresa of Ávila and Catherine of Siena—Doctors of the Church in 1970. The Word of Life mural had been completed six years earlier, in 1964. Understandable, perhaps, given the timing. But today, there are two more women Doctors of the Church: Sts. Thérèse of Lisieux and Hildegard of Bingen. Cognitive dissonance was settling in.
I wondered: Is it really such a stretch to include Mary Magdalene among the Apostles? Jesus called and chose the Twelve Apostles by name, but Mary Magdalene was the first to encounter the risen Christ at the empty tomb and announce the Resurrection. She is, after all, traditionally known as the Apostle to the Apostles. Her absence is a miss.
The covering of murals, the removal of statues, and the censorship of art have become the subject of intense debate in recent years—raising difficult questions about history, memory, and the role of public spaces in shaping how societies understand their past. Before one jumps to conclusions about what should be done, or not, I do think it's important to consider the time/era during which a piece was created, the artist's motive or purpose, the message they meant to send, and the impact it has had both in the past and present.
I've done that, and I've spoken with several people in leadership at the University about my feelings and my belief. Let me be very clear: I do not want the original artwork altered, taken down, amended, or changed. No. I would simply like figures of women—saints, scholars, and thinkers in Catholic thought—to be ADDED. I envision their likenesses designed and placed on the panels along the sides. You might be saying, "so you do want it to change." Okay, if that is how you see it. I think the integrity of the original piece can stand alone. I still think adding on is more than a plus.
Women are already absent from the altar. I would rather they not be left out of great Catholic art, too.
I asked my students what they thought of my proposal. A strong majority initially voted to keep the mural as it is. Their suggestion was to honor the women of the Church in a different place and commission a separate work of art.
But when I explained that the title "Doctor of the Church" means teacher, and that this mural adorns the front of the University Library, they hit pause. Isn't the purpose of a great Catholic university like Notre Dame to form men and women in Catholic thought, writing, teaching, and preaching? Should we not dream of a future Doctor of the Church who holds an ND degree?
The addition of women could serve as a wonderful lesson and witness to the contributions, examples, stories, and sacrifices of women of faith throughout the history of the Church. What better place than the University of Notre Dame? And what better time than Game Day?
Photo Credits
Doctors of the Church
Touchdown in Green
Word of Life Mural


























