As I watched Scottie Scheffler hoist the Claret Jug after his first Open Championship victory, it was hard to reconcile the moment with something he had said just the day before: “This is not a fulfilling life.” Those were the words of the world’s No. 1 golfer on the eve of the final major of the year. According to ESPN, Scheffler admitted, “That is something that I wrestle with on a daily basis.” He continued, “It’s like showing up at the Masters every year—why do I want to win this golf tournament so badly? Why do I want to win the Open Championship so badly? I don’t know, because if I win, it’s going to be awesome for two minutes.”
He went even further: “I’m not out here to inspire the next generation of golfers. I’m not out here to inspire someone to be the best player in the world, because what’s the point?” He paused and asked, “Does this make any sense?”
Yes. And that's exactly why Sports and Spirituality would like weigh in
It's natural for golf writers is to compare Scottie to the other greats in the game. ESPN writes, "Scheffler, 29, is now the third-youngest player with 15 PGA Tour victories and four majors; only Tiger (24) and Jack Nicklaus (25) were younger. He is only the fourth golfer to win the Masters, PGA Championship and The Open before turning 30; Woods, Nicklaus and Gary Player were the others. That's elite company." Indeed it is.
There’s value in understanding a player’s impact by comparing them to those who came before, but Scottie Scheffler’s story is still unfolding. Yes, he’s made significant strides in his short game—switching from a blade to a mallet putter and adopting a claw grip for short putts has paid dividends. And sure, his unorthodox "dancing feet" contribute to the power and consistency of his swing.
But there’s something more—something different. It’s what makes fellow pros like Xander Schauffele admit, “He’s a tough man to beat, and when you see his name up on the leaderboard, it sucks for us.”
So what is that difference? Does Scottie know it? Do we? And once we recognize it—what do we do with it?
I’m not an expert on Scottie Scheffler—I’ll leave the swing analysis, stats, and shot-tracking to the golf pros and technicians. But as a fan—of golf, of sports, and of the 6'3" Texan (originally from New Jersey)—I find myself drawn to something deeper. Pablo Torre, co-host of Pardon the Interruption, captured it perfectly:
"He talks about the game like he is a character in a documentary about his life, twenty years from now. He has this sort of existential wisdom as to why he is not fulfilled by it, but he is nonetheless obsessed with it. He's not the conventional superstar. He's not going to say ‘I want to be an all-time immortal, I want to be a global superstar.’ He's different."
And that difference is exactly what makes him so compelling. It was evident in the interview, where he openly shared the questions he wrestles with—about the game’s purpose and how he lives with its uncertainty. But it was also on display in his final-round pairing with Haotong Li.
Several times, I looked up at the screen and saw something rare for a Sunday at a major: Scheffler and Li laughing, smiling, and playing at a relaxed, almost unhurried pace. Golf Magazine writes, “It was actually super calm, and he’s such a lovely guy to play with,” Li said afterward. “We joked with each other a bit—it was just so nice.” This wasn’t the typical high-stakes showdown or theatrical duel between golf’s titans. Instead, it was two pros—one the world’s best—sharing genuine joy in the moment. That was different.
Given the gravity of the tournament, the massive prize purse, and the pressure that usually defines a major Sunday, the joy I witnessed between them made me appreciate Scottie Scheffler all the more. But where do we go from here? And where does Scottie go? Where should he go?
If I were Scottie Scheffler’s spiritual director (happy to take that call, Scottie!), I’d encourage him to rest in appreciation. I’d remind him not to get caught up in the “two minutes later” the media keeps asking about—or to look too far ahead. Instead: savor the success. Taste the tears.
Being fully present in a moment or holding on to one while it is happening is a spiritual discipline. I’ve seen it in sports and beyond.
For example, when the San Francisco Giants won their first World Series in 2010, I clung to that title—World Series Champions—everyday until the Cardinals claimed it in 2011. I remember going to the ball park the entire year after and looking at that WS banner with utter delight.
Scottie, you are the 2025 Open Champion. That is yours. No one can take it from you. Enjoy every minute of it.
It’s no accident that the Masters champion is often seen wearing the iconic green jacket during interviews and on late-night television in the days and weeks following the tournament. Just as two people proudly embrace their title of "newlyweds" after a wedding, certain moments in life come with visible signs or symbols. Whether its a jacket or a ring, a name change or a title, these markers allow others to recognize and celebrate the leap and/or accomplishment someone has made. They spark joy, invite applause, and affirm a significant transition. I believe this is the stuff of a fulfilling life.
Scottie already does this, but I think it's ever important to bring others into the fold. He thanked his wife, and held his son on the biggest stage. He honored his parents and sisters. He praised his coach and caddy. His success is their success. No one achieves great things by themselves. He doesn't need the reminder but when asking How or Why? it's important to consider others, too. An individual sport makes this question less likely, both also that much more important.
Finally, Scottie should know is that he’s far from the first to feel this kind of angst. He’s not the only existential athlete. Yes, he’s different—but in this way, he’s not.
An important article we read in my class, “Experiencing Life’s Flow: Sports and the Spiritual Life” by Patrick Kelly, SJ, echoes Scottie’s questions and concerns. It reminds us that even those who reach the pinnacle of their sport can be left asking, “Is this it?”
Jackson had learned from his days as a champion player with the New York Knicks that “winning is ephemeral.” He writes about the Knicks winning the N.B.A. championship against the Los Angeles Lakers in the 1971-72 season. Two days after the victory, the team was in New York for a celebration with families and friends, where movie stars like Robert Redford and Dustin Hoffman had also gathered. Jackson felt it should have been the happiest day of his life. “But the intense feeling of connection with my teammates I had experienced in L.A. seemed like a distant memory. Instead of being overwhelmed with joy, I felt empty and confused. Was this it? I kept saying to myself. Is this what was supposed to bring me happiness? Clearly the answer lay somewhere else.”
Scottie Scheffler isn’t the only one raising questions about what makes a life fulfilling. He’s not the only one asking, “What’s the point?”
His honesty, his humility, his quiet conviction, his positive presence on the course amidst those questions and quandaries stand out. I appreciate the similarity and the difference. I’d dare say: golf is a better game because of you. Congratulations to you Scottie, your family and your team.
Photo Credits
Claret Jug
Laughing